← Back to Blog

Collision Repair · · 11 min

OEM vs. Aftermarket Parts: What Arizona Drivers Should Demand

The Anatomy of a Collision Repair: Defining OEM and Aftermarket Parts

When your vehicle is damaged in a collision, the parts used to repair it are not all created equal. Understanding the terminology is the first step in protecting your investment and your safety. The debate primarily centers on two categories: OEM and Aftermarket parts.

Original Equipment Manufacturer (OEM) Parts

An OEM part is a component made by your vehicle’s manufacturer or by a company contracted by that manufacturer. These are the exact same parts your car was assembled with at the factory. They are designed, engineered, and tested specifically for your vehicle's make, model, and year. When you use an OEM part, you are guaranteed:

  • Perfect Fit: The part will align precisely with the mounting points and surrounding body panels, ensuring consistent gaps and a factory-fresh appearance.
  • Uncompromised Quality: OEM parts adhere to the strict material,-strength, and durability standards set by the carmaker. They are built to last and perform as originally intended.
  • Safety Assurance: Crucial components like bumper reinforcements, brackets, and body panels are engineered to work together as part of your vehicle's integrated safety system, including crumple zones and airbag deployment timing. Using OEM parts ensures this system is not compromised.
  • Warranty Backing: OEM parts are backed by your vehicle manufacturer's warranty, providing an extra layer of protection and peace of mind.

Aftermarket Parts

Aftermarket parts are new parts produced by companies other than the original vehicle manufacturer. These companies reverse-engineer the OEM part to create their own version. While some aftermarket parts can be of high quality, the market is flooded with components that prioritize low cost over everything else. The primary motivation for their existence is to offer a cheaper alternative.

Key characteristics of aftermarket parts include:

  • Variable Quality: There is no single standard for aftermarket parts. Quality can range from acceptable to dangerously poor.
  • Potential Fitment Issues: Because they are reverse-engineered, they may not fit perfectly. Technicians often have to bend, drill, or force these parts into place, which compromises the integrity of the repair and can add hidden labor costs.
  • Questionable Materials: To cut costs, some aftermarket manufacturers use cheaper, thinner, or heavier materials that do not match the OEM specifications. This can affect everything from vehicle weight and balance to how the car reacts in a subsequent collision.
  • The "CAPA Certified" Myth: Some insurers point to CAPA (Certified Automotive Parts Association) certification as proof of quality. While CAPA provides a basic standard, it is not equivalent to the multi-million dollar crash testing and engineering that goes into OEM parts. It is a baseline, not a guarantee of OEM-level performance, especially concerning advanced safety systems.

The Insurance Company's Playbook: Why They Insist on Aftermarket Parts

Following an accident, your insurance adjuster may present you with an estimate that specifies aftermarket parts. Their reasoning is simple and singular: cost savings. Insurance companies are massive, for-profit businesses, and their primary fiduciary duty is to their shareholders, not to their policyholders' best interests.

Let's look at the real-world numbers. An OEM front bumper cover for a 2022 Honda CR-V might cost $425. A comparable aftermarket bumper cover might be just $220. An OEM radiator support could be $600, while its aftermarket counterpart is $350. When you multiply these savings across tens of thousands of claims per year, insurers save hundreds of millions of dollars. The problem is that this savings comes directly at the expense of your vehicle's safety, integrity, and value.

This pressure is amplified through Direct Repair Programs (DRPs). Insurers steer policyholders toward DRP shops with the promise of a faster, easier process. In reality, these shops have agreements with the insurance companies to control costs, which almost always involves prioritizing the use of cheap, aftermarket parts. This is why Advanced Collision Experts is not a DRP shop for any insurance company. Our contract is with you, the vehicle owner. We work to serve your best interests, not the insurer's bottom line.

Your Rights as an Arizona Driver: What the Law Says

You are not powerless in this situation. Arizona has specific regulations in place to protect consumers from unfair insurance practices. The key statute is found in the Arizona Administrative Code, Title 20, Chapter 6, Article 8 (A.A.C. R20-6-801), Unfair Claims Settlement Practices.

This regulation states an insurer can only specify the use of non-OEM parts if:

  1. The parts are of "like kind and quality" to the original parts. This is a subjective term that we, as repair experts, frequently challenge. A part that looks similar but doesn't have the same metallurgy or crash-test performance is not "like kind and quality."
  2. The written estimate provided to you must clearly and conspicuously identify each non-OEM part. They cannot hide this information in the fine print.
  3. The aftermarket part manufacturer must provide a warranty at least as good as the original manufacturer’s warranty.

Most importantly, the law in Arizona gives you the unquestionable right to choose your repair facility. You are under no obligation to use the insurer's preferred DRP shop. By choosing an independent advocate like Advanced Collision Experts, you put a team of I-CAR Gold Class certified professionals in your corner who will fight for the proper repair using the right parts.

The Real-World Risks of Aftermarket Parts: Safety, Fit, and Value

Why do we at ACE so passionately advocate for OEM parts? Because we have seen the disastrous consequences of using inferior aftermarket components firsthand. The risks are not theoretical; they are real and can affect your safety and your finances.

Compromised Safety Systems (ADAS)

Modern vehicles are equipped with Advanced Driver-Assistance Systems (ADAS) — a complex network of sensors, cameras, and radar that control features like automatic emergency braking, blind-spot monitoring, and lane-keep assist. These sensors are often mounted in or behind bumper covers, grilles, and side mirrors. An aftermarket part might:

  • Lack the precise mounting points for these sensors, causing them to be misaligned.
  • Be made from a material that interferes with the radar or camera operation.
  • Have a slightly different shape that reflects radar signals incorrectly.

A misaligned blind-spot monitor is worse than no monitor at all. A delayed automatic emergency braking system can be the difference between a close call and a catastrophic failure. Using OEM parts is the only way to guarantee these life-saving systems are calibrated and function exactly as the manufacturer intended.

Poor Fit, Finish, and Longevity

The cosmetic consequences of aftermarket parts are immediately obvious to a trained eye. You'll see inconsistent panel gaps—too wide in one area, too tight in another. Body lines won't match up from the fender to the door. The paint may not adhere properly or match the color and texture of the adjacent OEM panels because the underlying material is different. Over time, these parts may be more susceptible to rust, warping from the Arizona sun, or premature fading.

Guaranteed Diminished Value

Diminished Value is the loss in a vehicle's resale value after it has been wrecked and repaired. A professionally documented, OEM-only repair is the best way to mitigate this loss. Conversely, using aftermarket parts is a surefire way to maximize it. When you trade in or sell your vehicle, any savvy buyer, appraiser, or dealership will spot the signs of a cheap repair. The CarFax report may even note that non-OEM parts were used. This will result in a significantly lower offer—often a loss of thousands of dollars that far outweighs the few hundred dollars the insurance company saved on the initial repair. We are experts in helping our customers file and win Diminished Value claims, and the foundation of a strong claim is a repair done right. You can check your eligibility with our free diminished value checker.

The ACE Difference: We Are Your Advocate, Not the Insurer's

At Advanced Collision Experts, our entire business model is built on one principle: we work for you. Our allegiance is to the vehicle owner and to the uncompromising standards of a safe and proper repair. When you bring your vehicle to any of our locations in Scottsdale, Phoenix, Gilbert, or Payson, you are not just a number on a work order. You are our client, and we become your advocate.

Here's how we handle the parts-selection battle:

  1. Meticulous Blueprinting: We disassemble the damaged area to create a comprehensive repair plan, or "blueprint," based on official manufacturer procedures. Our estimate is written from the start with 100% OEM parts.
  2. Expert Negotiation: We submit our blueprint to the insurance company. When they inevitably push back and demand the use of cheaper parts, we counter with technical data, manufacturer position statements, and photographic evidence, building a case for why the OEM part is the only acceptable option for a safe repair.
  3. Total Transparency: We keep you informed throughout this process. We will explain the functional or safety difference between the OEM part and the aftermarket alternative the insurer wants to use. The final decision is always yours, but we will give you the expert information you need to make it.
  4. Unwavering Quality Control: Because we use the correct parts that are designed to fit, our technicians can perform the repair efficiently and effectively, restoring your vehicle to its pre-accident condition. We back our workmanship with a lifetime warranty, something we can only do because we use parts we trust.

Don't just accept your insurer's initial lowball estimate. It's a starting point for negotiation. Bring it to us for a no-obligation consultation. Get started today with a free estimate from the experts who have your back.

Navigating the Claim: Your Step-by-Step Guide

Feeling overwhelmed? Follow this simple process to protect yourself and your vehicle.

  1. After the Incident: Ensure everyone is safe, move vehicles if possible, and contact the authorities. Always request an official report. You may need to obtain your police report later.
  2. Inform the Insurer: Open a claim with your insurance company. Provide the basic facts, but do not agree to their repair method or their recommended shop. State clearly, "I am exercising my right to choose my own repair facility. I will be taking my vehicle to Advanced Collision Experts for an estimate."
  3. Get an Expert Estimate: Contact us at 480-847-2437 or bring your vehicle to one of our shops. We will perform a thorough inspection and write a proper repair plan.
  4. Let Us Handle the Hassle: Authorize us to communicate with your insurance adjuster. We will submit our estimate and expertly negotiate on your behalf to get the proper repair approved.
  5. Authorize the Right Repair: Once we have an agreed price with the insurer that meets our standards and your approval, we will begin the work of restoring your vehicle with precision and care.
  6. Finalize All Claims: After the repair, we can assist you with supplemental claims for a rental car, Diminished Value, or even navigating a potential total loss. Check out our total loss checker for more information.

Frequently Asked Questions About OEM vs. Aftermarket Parts

Can my insurance company legally force me to use aftermarket parts in Arizona?

No, they cannot force you. According to Arizona's Unfair Claims Settlement Practices regulations (A.A.C. R20-6-801), they can specify aftermarket parts on an estimate if they are disclosed and certified to be of "like kind and quality." However, this is a very gray area. As your chosen repair expert, we can challenge that assertion. Ultimately, you have the final say. You can insist on OEM parts and pay the cost difference out-of-pocket, or you can let a qualified shop like ACE negotiate on your behalf to get the OEM parts covered by the insurer.

How much more do OEM parts really cost?

The price difference varies widely by part and vehicle. A simple bracket might have a $20 difference. A complex part, like a modern LED headlight assembly, could be $1,800 for OEM versus $950 for an aftermarket version. For a moderate front-end collision, the total cost difference for using all OEM parts versus all aftermarket parts could easily be between $2,000 and $5,000. The insurance company pockets this savings while you are left with a lower-quality repair and a vehicle that has lost significant value.

Will using aftermarket parts void my car's manufacturer warranty?

This is a common concern. The Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act states that a vehicle manufacturer cannot void your entire warranty simply because you used an aftermarket part. However, if that specific aftermarket part fails and causes damage to other components, the manufacturer is not required to honor the warranty for that subsequent damage. For example, if you use an aftermarket radiator that fails and causes your engine to overheat, your powertrain warranty will not cover the resulting engine damage.

What if my car is older? Do I still need OEM parts?

Yes. The principles of safety, fit, and function do not change with the age of a vehicle. A 2014 model's crumple zones and structural integrity are just as important as a 2024 model's. For older vehicles where new OEM parts may be discontinued or cost-prohibitive, we often recommend using high-quality recycled OEM parts. These are original parts taken from a salvage vehicle that was not damaged in the same area. This provides the fit and quality of an OEM part at a more economical price point, and it is a far superior option to a new aftermarket part.

How can I tell if a shop used aftermarket parts on my car without my permission?

First, always demand a detailed, itemized final invoice that lists every single part replaced, including part numbers. OEM parts will have the manufacturer's official part number. You can then inspect the vehicle. Look for branding or logos stamped into the parts themselves—aftermarket parts will be blank or have a different brand name. Examine panel gaps and body lines under bright light. If they look uneven, it's a red flag. If you suspect a shop used non-approved parts, contact us at 480-847-2437 or info@acephx.com for a post-repair inspection.

Serving Drivers Across Arizona

Advanced Collision Experts operates four full-service auto body and collision repair centers across the Valley and Rim Country. Whether you need a free estimate, a diminished value report, or a total loss dispute review, you're only minutes from a certified ACE shop:

  • Scottsdale Auto Body Repair — 8625 E. McDowell Road. I-CAR Gold Class certified flagship serving Old Town, McCormick Ranch, DC Ranch, and Scottsdale Airpark.
  • Phoenix Auto Body Repair — 1727 E. Deer Valley Drive. Serving Downtown, Arcadia, Biltmore, Ahwatukee, Anthem, and Desert Ridge.
  • Gilbert Auto Body Repair — 1625 W. Sunrise Boulevard. East Valley specialists serving Power Ranch, Seville, Agritopia, and the Heritage District.
  • Payson Auto Body Repair — 201 N. Tonto Street. Rim Country's only full-service collision center serving Pine, Strawberry, Star Valley, and Christopher Creek.

All four locations bill insurance directly, accept every major carrier, and offer free courtesy rentals for non-driveable vehicles. Call (480) 847-2437 or get a free photo estimate.

Request a free photo estimate · Call (480) 847-2437