← Back to Blog

Collision Repair · · 11 min read

How Many Car Repair Estimates Do You Really Need?

Your Rights in Arizona: Debunking the Three-Estimate Myth

After the stress of a collision, the last thing you want is a complicated and confusing repair process. One of the most persistent myths in the auto body industry is that you are required to get three separate estimates for your vehicle's repairs. Let's be clear: in the state of Arizona, this is unequivocally false. Understanding your rights is the first step toward a smooth and proper repair.

The Myth of the Three Estimates

The “three estimate” rule is a holdover from a time when insurance companies wanted vehicle owners to do the legwork of finding the lowest possible bid. The logic was that by getting three quotes, the insurer could justify paying out on the cheapest one. This practice puts the focus entirely on price, not on the quality, safety, or completeness of the repair. While an insurer might suggest you get multiple bids, you are not legally obligated to do so. This suggestion is often a tactic to steer you toward a low-cost repair, which may not be in your vehicle's—or your family's—best interest.

Arizona Law and Your Freedom of Choice

Your most powerful tool as a consumer is your right to choose. Arizona state law is firmly on your side in this matter. Specifically, Arizona Revised Statute § 20-461, which outlines unfair claim settlement practices, states that an insurance company cannot require that repairs be made by a particular repair shop. The Arizona Department of Insurance and Financial Institutions (DIFI) enforces these regulations to protect consumers.

This means:

  • You have the absolute right to choose which body shop repairs your vehicle.
  • Your insurance company cannot force you to use one of their “preferred” or “network” shops.
  • You only need one estimate—from the repair facility you have chosen.

Your primary goal should be to find a single, highly-qualified collision repair center that you trust to restore your vehicle to pre-accident condition. That shop will then work directly with the insurance company on your behalf.

Why Insurers Suggest Multiple Bids

When an insurance adjuster suggests getting other estimates, it’s rarely about ensuring a quality repair. It's about cost control. They hope that one of the estimates will be significantly lower, giving them leverage to pay less on the claim. However, a lower price almost always comes at a cost: non-OEM parts, skipped procedures, or inexperienced technicians. A reputable shop prioritizes a safe and complete repair according to manufacturer specifications, and they have the expertise to document and justify the necessary procedures to the insurer.

One Comprehensive Estimate vs. Multiple Bids

Now that you know you aren't required to shop around, the question becomes: what is the best strategy? In most cases, focusing your energy on finding the right collision partner is far more effective than collecting a stack of potentially conflicting estimates.

The Case for a Single, Quality-Focused Estimate

Instead of running all over town, invest your time in researching and selecting one top-tier auto body shop. Look for a facility with OEM certifications, positive reviews, and a commitment to ongoing training and technology. Once you've chosen this shop, let them be your advocate. They will perform a thorough inspection and prepare a single, comprehensive estimate that details every necessary step to repair your vehicle correctly. This estimate becomes the foundation for the entire claim. It's a blueprint for quality, not a bid in a race to the bottom.

When Multiple Estimates Might Make Sense

While one estimate from a trusted shop is the gold standard for insurance claims, there are a few scenarios where getting more than one might be practical:

  • Paying Out-of-Pocket: If the damage is minor (e.g., a small dent or scrape) and you plan to pay for it yourself to avoid an insurance claim, shopping around can help you understand the market rate and find a price that fits your budget.
  • Second Opinions: If you get an estimate from a shop and something feels off, or you feel they aren't being transparent, getting a second opinion from a more reputable facility can provide peace of mind and a valuable point of comparison.
  • Due Diligence: For some, seeing two or three estimates helps them feel more educated about the process. However, this often leads to more confusion, as the estimates will likely vary significantly.

The Problem with Comparing Estimates

Comparing estimates from different shops is rarely an “apples-to-apples” comparison. A low-ball estimate might look appealing, but it's often a red flag. Discrepancies between estimates can arise from several factors:

  • Parts Usage: One shop may quote Original Equipment Manufacturer (OEM) parts, while another quotes cheaper aftermarket or salvaged parts.
  • Thoroughness: A quick visual estimate might miss significant hidden damage to sensors, brackets, or structural components. A lower estimate is often an incomplete one.
  • Labor Rates & Times: Labor rates vary, but more importantly, the estimated time to perform a specific repair can differ. A shop that follows manufacturer-specified repair procedures will quote the correct amount of time, while another might cut corners.

What a Professional Repair Estimate Includes

A legitimate estimate is more than just a number at the bottom of a page. It's a detailed, line-by-line document that serves as a blueprint for your vehicle's restoration. Knowing what to look for will help you identify a quality shop and a trustworthy estimate.

The Line-by-Line Breakdown

A professional estimate from a shop like ACE is meticulously organized. It will typically include:

  • Parts: Each part is listed with its price and type (OEM, Aftermarket, Reconditioned, or Recycled/Used). We believe in transparency and will discuss the pros and cons of each option with you.
  • Labor Operations: This section details the work to be done, with labor hours assigned to each task (e.g., Body Labor, Paint Labor, Mechanical Labor, Structural Labor).
  • Paint & Materials: This covers the cost of base coats, clear coats, and all other materials needed for a factory-quality finish.
  • Sublet Operations: This includes any work that will be sent out to a specialist, such as wheel alignments, glass replacement, or ADAS recalibration.
  • Summary: A clear total of all costs.

The Critical Importance of a Full Teardown

The most significant limitation of a preliminary visual estimate is that it can't see through metal. Modern vehicles are incredibly complex. A seemingly minor bumper scuff could be hiding damage to parking sensors, radar units, foam absorbers, and reinforcement bars. A proper, accurate estimate can only be written after a partial teardown, where technicians remove the damaged outer panels to inspect the intricate systems underneath. While a photo-based estimate is a great starting point, a physical teardown is non-negotiable for an accurate repair plan. Our free online estimate tool is an excellent first step to get the process started from the comfort of your home, but it will always be followed by a thorough in-person inspection at one of our facilities.

Red Flags to Watch For in an Estimate

Be wary of estimates that seem too good to be true. Here are some common red flags:

  • Vague or Lump-Sum Pricing: Phrases like “Repair quarter panel” with a single price and no breakdown are a sign of a lazy or deceptive estimate.
  • An Unusually Low Price: This almost always indicates missed damage, the planned use of inferior parts, or skipped safety procedures.
  • No Mention of Scans or Calibrations: Modern cars require pre-repair and post-repair diagnostic scans and Advanced Driver-Assistance Systems (ADAS) recalibration. Failure to include these is a major safety concern.
  • Pressure to Commit Immediately: A professional shop will give you time to review the estimate and ask questions.

Navigating the Insurance Process with Your Chosen Estimate

Once you've selected your repair partner and have a comprehensive estimate in hand, the next step is managing the insurance claim. An expert body shop will guide you through this, acting as your advocate to ensure your vehicle is repaired properly.

Submitting the Estimate and The Role of the Adjuster

Your chosen shop will submit their detailed estimate to the at-fault party's insurance company (or your own, depending on the claim). The insurer will assign an adjuster to review the estimate. It's common for the insurance company to write their own, often lower, estimate based on their software and guidelines. This is where the negotiation begins. It is your shop's job—not yours—to negotiate with the adjuster and justify every procedure on their estimate, ensuring the insurer pays for a safe and complete repair.

Understanding Supplements: The Reality of Collision Repair

It is almost a guarantee that additional damage will be found once the vehicle is disassembled and repairs begin. When this happens, the shop writes a “supplement.” This is an addition to the original estimate that covers the newly discovered damage. For example, a bent bracket or a cracked sensor found behind a bumper cover would be added via a supplement. Your shop will document this damage with photos and submit the supplement to the insurance company for approval. This is a normal part of the process and a key reason why the initial insurance estimate is rarely the final cost.

What If the Insurer's Estimate is Too Low?

This happens constantly. Insurance adjusters are trained to minimize costs, and their initial estimates often omit necessary procedures or specify low-quality parts. Do not be alarmed. This is precisely why you choose a high-quality shop. An expert team, like the ones at our Scottsdale and Gilbert locations, will provide documentation, manufacturer position statements, and technical data to prove to the insurer why certain procedures and parts are required. They work on your behalf to get the claim approved for what is right, not just what is cheap.

Beyond the Repair: Diminished Value and Total Loss

A major accident has financial implications beyond the repair bill. Two key concepts to understand are Diminished Value and Total Loss.

  • Diminished Value (DV): Even if your car is repaired perfectly, it now has an accident history, which reduces its resale value. This loss in value is called Diminished Value, and you may be entitled to compensation for it from the at-fault party's insurer. ACE offers a specialized Diminished Value report to help you prove and claim what you are owed.
  • Total Loss: If the cost to repair your vehicle plus its salvage value exceeds its Actual Cash Value (ACV), the insurer will declare it a total loss. Sometimes, their valuation is too low. If you believe your car is worth more than the insurer is offering, you have the right to dispute it. Our Total Loss evaluation service can provide the appraisal and documentation you need to negotiate a fair settlement.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I have to use the body shop my insurance company recommends?

No. Under Arizona law (ARS § 20-461), you have the absolute right to have your vehicle repaired at any shop you choose. Your insurance company cannot require you to use one of their “preferred” network shops. This freedom of choice is a critical consumer protection right.

Why are some car repair estimates so much lower than others?

Lower estimates are often a sign of an incomplete inspection or a plan to use inferior parts. They may fail to account for hidden damage that's only visible after a teardown, or they might quote cheaper aftermarket parts instead of OEM parts. A quality-focused shop writes an estimate for a complete and safe repair, not just the cheapest one.

What is a “supplemental estimate” or “supplement”?

A supplement is an addition to the original estimate created when hidden or additional damage is discovered after the initial inspection and teardown. This is a standard and expected part of the collision repair process, as the full extent of damage is often not visible until the vehicle is disassembled. The shop documents the new damage and gets approval from the insurance company.

Can I just get one estimate if I'm paying for the repairs myself?

Yes, absolutely. If you're paying out-of-pocket, it's even more important to choose a shop you trust to do the job right the first time. Your focus should be on finding a partner who will provide a high-quality, lasting repair for a fair price, rather than just finding the lowest possible bid which could lead to problems down the road.

How can I get a preliminary estimate quickly?

Many modern shops offer photo-based estimating tools that allow you to get a preliminary quote quickly. You can use our free photo-estimate request to upload photos of your damage and receive a fast, initial assessment. Remember, this is a starting point, and a final, accurate estimate will require a thorough, in-person inspection by our expert technicians.

Ultimately, navigating the post-accident process is about choosing the right partner. Instead of asking “how many estimates do I need for car repair,” the better question is “who can I trust to repair my car correctly?” A single, comprehensive estimate from a certified, reputable shop is your most powerful tool. It sets the standard for quality and gives your chosen advocate the documentation they need to ensure your insurance company pays for a safe, complete, and proper repair. For more insights, feel free to browse our other articles on the ACE collision repair blog.

Ready to get started with an estimate you can trust? The expert team at Advanced Collision Experts is here to help. Call us today at 480-847-2437 or use our simple online tool to get a free estimate and let us handle the rest.

Request a free photo estimate · Call (480) 847-2437